Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft: Java Edition'
  1. Minecraft: Java Edition
  2. MC-160457

Destroying a bee hive or a bee nest in creative mode causes it to drop as an item

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Works As Intended
    • None
    • 19w36a
    • None
    • Confirmed
    • Creative
    • (Unassigned)

      The bug

      When destroying a beehive and/or a beenest in creative mode it's drop as an item.

      How to reproduce

      1. Place a beehive or a beenest in creative mode
      2. Break it
        โ†’  It's dropped as an item

        1. 2019-09-04_15.37.01.png
          2019-09-04_15.37.01.png
          419 kB
        2. 2019-09-04_15.37.07.png
          2019-09-04_15.37.07.png
          631 kB
        3. 2019-09-04_15.37.11.png
          2019-09-04_15.37.11.png
          607 kB
        4. 2019-09-04_15.37.21.png
          2019-09-04_15.37.21.png
          582 kB

          [MC-160457] Destroying a bee hive or a bee nest in creative mode causes it to drop as an item

          Junio added a comment -

          "they drop because they have nbt data", yeah i agree
          is important to prevent bee's inside it removed

          Junio added a comment - "they drop because they have nbt data", yeah i agree is important to prevent bee's inside it removed

          Virgil Fabre added a comment -

          "they drop because they have nbt data."
          Well why doesn't chest, furnace, and other NBT blocks doesn't drop when broken?
          I'd re open this issue and make it drop nothing. If someone want to get a block with NBT the person will use the ctrl middleclick like supposed to in creative mod.

          I consider this a bug.
          We have function to copy NBT data. If we want it we can get it. No need to drop the item.

          Virgil Fabre added a comment - "they drop because they have nbt data." Well why doesn't chest, furnace, and other NBT blocks doesn't drop when broken? I'd re open this issue and make it drop nothing. If someone want to get a block with NBT the person will use the ctrl middleclick like supposed to in creative mod. I consider this a bug. We have function to copy NBT data. If we want it we can get it. No need to drop the item.

          [Mod] violine1101 added a comment -

          I've created a new ticket about empty bee hives/nests dropping (shulker boxes don't drop if they're empty): MC-164992

          [Mod] violine1101 added a comment - I've created a new ticket about empty bee hives/nests dropping (shulker boxes don't drop if they're empty): MC-164992

          leasoncre added a comment -

          they should at least add some functionality to where if you hold a modifier key (like CTRL) it won't drop an item. it is rather annoying.

          leasoncre added a comment - they should at least add some functionality to where if you hold a modifier key (like CTRL) it won't drop an item. it is rather annoying.

          Pink added a comment -

          they drop because they have nbt data.

          Pink added a comment - they drop because they have nbt data.

          Kyle Cuthbert added a comment -

          Then they should at least drop nothing when empty. These don't even stack with empty beehives

          Kyle Cuthbert added a comment - Then they should at least drop nothing when empty. These don't even stack with empty beehives

          Nixinova added a comment -

          The beehives will drop themselves in creative because it saves the NBT data of the bees inside when broken. Its basically the same as mining a bee hive with Silk Touch in survival mode.

          Nixinova added a comment - The beehives will drop themselves in creative because it saves the NBT data of the bees inside when broken. Its basically the same as mining a bee hive with Silk Touch in survival mode.

          Kyle Cuthbert added a comment -

          "No other block does this in Minecraft" Except shulker boxes, but that makes sense for obvious reasons, where this doesn't as far as I can tell.

          Kyle Cuthbert added a comment - "No other block does this in Minecraft" Except shulker boxes, but that makes sense for obvious reasons, where this doesn't as far as I can tell.

          Mykola Kikets added a comment -

          I agreed. And by the way, I created that with 19w37a (my Issue marked as resolved because of duplication (to your issue)

          Mykola Kikets added a comment - I agreed. And by the way, I created that with 19w37a (my Issue marked as resolved because of duplication (to your issue)

          qmagnet added a comment - - edited

          How on earth is this Works As Intended? No other block does this in Minecraft. So basically if you're building in Creative mode all the bee blocks you break leave items all over the place and cause you to clean up the mess? Was this falsely labeled or misread? No way this is WAI.

          qmagnet added a comment - - edited How on earth is this Works As Intended? No other block does this in Minecraft. So basically if you're building in Creative mode all the bee blocks you break leave items all over the place and cause you to clean up the mess? Was this falsely labeled or misread? No way this is WAI.

            Unassigned Unassigned
            TheBoy358 TheBoy358
            Votes:
            1 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved:
              CHK: