Trying to put Minecraft in fullscreen on my second monitor crashes the game

What I do to reproduce this: I open the game up normally, it actually opens up already in fullscreen on my laptop's screen, but then if I move the game to my second monitor and try to make it fullscreen, the game crashes. The error code I am given in the crash log is -1073740791, which I know is a common crash number, however the fixes recommended for that crash don't seem to do anything in this case.

I am using the latest Nvidia GeForce Game Ready Driver (452.06) so I don't think that that's my issue.

Now, to re-iterate, the game can run in fullscreen on my laptop without a problem, however as soon as I try to put the game in fullscreen on my second monitor, the game crashes.