Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft: Java Edition'
  1. Minecraft: Java Edition
  2. MC-218979

Cave ceilings and floors sometimes too flat or blocky

XMLWordPrintable

    • Confirmed
    • World generation

      The cave floors or ceilings sometimes generate a huge flat surface area which seems unnatural, even the plains are less flat than this. The transition from floor or ceilings to the wall are jarring. We can see the floor generation is contrary to the ceiling or vice versa (sometimes both). They seems to generate quite more often with aquifers. There are no stronghold structure nearby.

      Seed: -1996202605590230192

      I'm afraid this report would be mistaken as an opinion but I don't think this is intentional. Overall, I'm loving this new update and keep up the great work!  

       

      Edit: It seems the flat floors starts to appear on 21w10a but flat ceilings can be found since 21w06a

       

        1. 2021-03-10_12.47.25.png
          2021-03-10_12.47.25.png
          817 kB
        2. 2021-03-11_15.11.42.png
          2021-03-11_15.11.42.png
          1.11 MB
        3. 2021-03-11_15.13.43.png
          2021-03-11_15.13.43.png
          1.98 MB
        4. 2021-03-11_15.16.32.png
          2021-03-11_15.16.32.png
          2.70 MB
        5. 2021-03-11_15.20.12.png
          2021-03-11_15.20.12.png
          1.97 MB
        6. 2021-03-11_15.22.49.png
          2021-03-11_15.22.49.png
          1.86 MB
        7. 2021-03-11_15.32.39.png
          2021-03-11_15.32.39.png
          1.98 MB
        8. 2021-03-11_15.33.35.png
          2021-03-11_15.33.35.png
          2.14 MB
        9. 2021-03-12_19.11.27.png
          2021-03-12_19.11.27.png
          2.21 MB
        10. 2021-03-13_09.20.00.png
          2021-03-13_09.20.00.png
          1.80 MB
        11. 2021-03-13_09.27.20.png
          2021-03-13_09.27.20.png
          2.23 MB
        12. 2021-03-18_02.29.46.png
          2021-03-18_02.29.46.png
          2.98 MB
        13. 2021-03-18_02.37.02.png
          2021-03-18_02.37.02.png
          2.46 MB
        14. 2021-03-18_03.08.58.png
          2021-03-18_03.08.58.png
          1.76 MB

          [MC-218979] Cave ceilings and floors sometimes too flat or blocky

          Durrani Afiq added a comment - - edited

          Really liked the fix on 21w11a so far. My guess that some of it has to do with aquifers for the floor was right. Although some of the ceilings can still be found flat but it's less common and doesn't bother too much.

          Some large flat ceiling can still be found on 21w11a.

          Durrani Afiq added a comment - - edited Really liked the fix on 21w11a so far. My guess that some of it has to do with aquifers for the floor was right. Although some of the ceilings can still be found flat but it's less common and doesn't bother too much. Some large flat ceiling can still be found on 21w11a.

          Andrew Edmunds added a comment -

          Can confirm as well, it seems this may be a bug with aquafer generation. I believe these flat floors are supposed to be filled with water. These problems seem to also happen mainly below y=8.

          Andrew Edmunds added a comment - Can confirm as well, it seems this may be a bug with aquafer generation. I believe these flat floors are supposed to be filled with water. These problems seem to also happen mainly below y=8.

          James added a comment - - edited

          Can confirm, I reported this bug in MC-218734 with the seed -1695745861.

          James added a comment - - edited Can confirm, I reported this bug in  MC-218734 with the seed -1695745861.

          [Mod] Avoma added a comment - - edited

          Here's another example of where you can see this.

          Seed: -205621722095813482
Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:overworld run tp @s -414.43 -10.93 -328.32 -229.01 23.51

          [Mod] Avoma added a comment - - edited Here's another example of where you can see this. Seed: -205621722095813482 Coordinates: /execute in minecraft:overworld run tp @s -414.43 -10.93 -328.32 -229.01 23.51

            hkniberg hkniberg
            smowu Durrani Afiq
            Votes:
            6 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved:
              CHK: