Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft: Java Edition'
  1. Minecraft: Java Edition
  2. MC-279789

All but two crops have the #minecraft:mineable/axe tag

XMLWordPrintable

    • Confirmed
    • Block states
    • Low
    • Gameplay

      Relates to: MC-230411 MC-251037 MC-251043 MC-279203 MC-279783 MC-279784 MC-279786 MC-279787 MC-279788

      The bug

      The tag #minecraft:mineable/axe is intended for controlling blocks which can be mined faster with an axe than not, but that in both cases take a nonzero amount of time to break. For some reason, all types of crop besides two are part of this block tag, despite it being meaningless in this sense, as all crop types take no time to break under any circumstances.

      Having these blocks in this tag is confusing for data pack creators, and also contributes to visual bloat on the debug screen. The fact that two types of crop aren't part of this tag also makes things inconsistent.

      How to reproduce

      1. Look at a melon or pumpkin stem, wheat crops, carrots, potatoes, beetroots or nether wart
      2. Press F3
      3. Observe the block tags
      4. For comparison, look at a torchflower crop or pitcher crop

      Expected results

      None of these blocks would belong to the tag #minecraft:mineable/axe.

      Actual results

      All of them do, besides pitcher crops and torchflower crops.

      How to fix

      Remove these blocks from this tag.

        1. 2025-01-25_13.05.28.png
          2025-01-25_13.05.28.png
          480 kB
        2. 2025-01-25_13.05.29.png
          2025-01-25_13.05.29.png
          447 kB
        3. 2025-01-25_13.05.31.png
          2025-01-25_13.05.31.png
          486 kB
        4. 2025-01-25_13.05.33.png
          2025-01-25_13.05.33.png
          398 kB
        5. 2025-01-25_13.05.53.png
          2025-01-25_13.05.53.png
          399 kB
        6. 2025-01-25_13.05.54.png
          2025-01-25_13.05.54.png
          428 kB
        7. 2025-01-25_13.05.55.png
          2025-01-25_13.05.55.png
          342 kB
        8. 2025-01-25_13.05.56.png
          2025-01-25_13.05.56.png
          384 kB
        9. 2025-01-25_13.06.07.png
          2025-01-25_13.06.07.png
          448 kB
        10. 2025-01-25_13.06.09.png
          2025-01-25_13.06.09.png
          387 kB
        11. 2025-01-25_13.06.11.png
          2025-01-25_13.06.11.png
          457 kB

            Unassigned Unassigned
            muzikbike Connor Steppie
            Votes:
            1 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            2 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              CHK: