Uploaded image for project: 'Minecraft: Java Edition'
  1. Minecraft: Java Edition
  2. MC-55754

Overly light-sensitive Crops

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Duplicate
    • None
    • Minecraft 14w21b
    • None
    • Mac OS X, unknown java version.
    • Unconfirmed

      Crops that were growable in 14w20b pop out in 14w21b, unless the light level is the highest. The crops will pop out even when the light level is 12, more than sufficient for them to grow (if I understand the code correctly.)

      I have searched for other tickets that fit this description, I found none, if there is one, I apologize for not seeing it.

        1. 14w20b.png
          14w20b.png
          325 kB
        2. 14w21b.png
          14w21b.png
          299 kB
        3. 14w21b (lightlevel 7).png
          14w21b (lightlevel 7).png
          527 kB
        4. 14w21b (lightlevel 8).png
          14w21b (lightlevel 8).png
          637 kB
        5. Light level12.png
          Light level12.png
          210 kB
        6. Light Level 12.png
          Light Level 12.png
          188 kB
        7. Light Level8.png
          Light Level8.png
          119 kB
        8. Light level 8.png
          Light level 8.png
          193 kB

          [MC-55754] Overly light-sensitive Crops

          Kumasasa added a comment -

          In fact there is an issue in 14w21b compared to 14w20b, see MC-56041

          Kumasasa added a comment - In fact there is an issue in 14w21b compared to 14w20b, see MC-56041

          Galen Dolkas added a comment -

          Tested it in a different world, did not occur. I conclude that there is another cause to the phenomenon.

          Galen Dolkas added a comment - Tested it in a different world, did not occur. I conclude that there is another cause to the phenomenon.

          Galen Dolkas added a comment -

          At a light level bellow 7, yes, they are intended to pop out. But this happened when the light level was 8 at the lowest.

          Galen Dolkas added a comment - At a light level bellow 7, yes, they are intended to pop out. But this happened when the light level was 8 at the lowest.

          Kumasasa added a comment -

          Confirmed for 14w21b:
          Pop out when lightlevel is 7 or less (maybe intended)

          This is intended, see the fix of MC-30877 and http://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Light

          Kumasasa added a comment - Confirmed for 14w21b: Pop out when lightlevel is 7 or less (maybe intended) This is intended, see the fix of MC-30877 and http://minecraft.gamepedia.com/Light

          Marcono1234 added a comment -

          Confirmed for 14w21b:
          Pop out when lightlevel is 7 or less (maybe intended)

          *Added screenshots

          Can you maybe make some screenshots too, while having the "F3"/Debug window open and standing on exact spot (that it shows the lightlevel)?

          Marcono1234 added a comment - Confirmed for 14w21b: Pop out when lightlevel is 7 or less (maybe intended) *Added screenshots Can you maybe make some screenshots too, while having the "F3"/Debug window open and standing on exact spot (that it shows the lightlevel)?

          Kumasasa added a comment -

          Please redo the screenshots with enabled debug screen (F3)

          Kumasasa added a comment - Please redo the screenshots with enabled debug screen (F3)

          Galen Dolkas added a comment -

          This is very different. Crops are of course supposed to pop out when the light level is too low, but at 8? or at 12? thats not how its supposed to work.

          Galen Dolkas added a comment - This is very different. Crops are of course supposed to pop out when the light level is too low, but at 8? or at 12? thats not how its supposed to work.

          Dlawso the Really Lucky Rabbit added a comment -

          Works as intended. See MC-30877

          Dlawso the Really Lucky Rabbit added a comment - Works as intended. See MC-30877

            Unassigned Unassigned
            moriki Galen Dolkas
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            2 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: